The persistent myth that muscle soreness is an indicator of a good workout has been thoroughly debunked, yet it still influences fitness culture.
Story Highlights
- Muscle soreness, or DOMS, is not a reliable marker of effective training or muscle growth.
- This misconception originated in the 1980s and persists today despite scientific evidence to the contrary.
- Fitness experts emphasize training metrics like progressive overload over soreness.
- Chasing soreness can lead to overtraining and hinder muscle growth.
The Misconception of DOMS as a Workout Indicator
Delayed onset muscle soreness (DOMS) is often viewed as a sign of a successful workout, but research shows it is simply an indicator of muscle damage. The soreness, which peaks 24 to 72 hours after exercise, results from microtrauma and inflammation, particularly in response to eccentric exercises. However, this does not correlate directly with muscle growth or training quality. Instead, it can impair recovery and force output temporarily.
Despite its prevalence, the belief that DOMS equates to effective training has no scientific basis. Meta-analyses from the 1990s to 2010s clarify that while DOMS indicates muscle damage, it does not measure progress or hypertrophy. Instead, progressive overload—gradually increasing the weight, frequency, or number of repetitions in your strength training routine—remains the gold standard for muscle growth.
Watch:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HXfLW8Rboj0
Got a health question? Ask our AI doctor instantly, it’s free.
The Role of Fitness Professionals and Researchers
Exercise physiologists and fitness professionals play a vital role in debunking the DOMS myth. They emphasize the importance of evidence-based practices in training. Researchers conduct studies to understand the mechanisms of DOMS, revealing that it is more about adaptation than actual muscle growth. These findings help shape training guidelines that prioritize sustainable progress over chasing soreness.
Fitness trainers and gyms are key in educating clients about the inefficacy of soreness as a training metric. By focusing on client progress and retention, they provide training regimens that avoid the pitfalls of soreness chasing. This shift in focus helps clients achieve long-term fitness goals without risking overtraining or injury.
Start your health journey in under a minute.
Impact on Fitness Culture and Industry
The persistence of the DOMS myth has broad implications. In the short term, individuals who chase soreness may experience overtraining, altered biomechanics, and reduced motivation due to perceived ineffectiveness of their regimen. Long-term, this can impede hypertrophy and increase injury risk due to excessive eccentric exercises.
As the fitness industry pivots towards metrics that accurately reflect progress, such as progressive overload, the market for recovery tools continues to grow. Massage, compression garments, and other effective recovery techniques gain popularity, promoting sustainable training practices and reducing dropout rates.
Smart health starts here, try My Healthy Doc today.
Sources:
Massage and Recovery: A Meta-Analysis
Stretching and Soreness: Debunking the Myth
Is Muscle Soreness a Reliable Indicator of a Good Workout?
Why Soreness Isn’t a Sign of a Great Workout
